Login

— 6 minutes — Mark Eckert

Identifying What Works in Your Sync Catalog

Short answer: To identify what works in your catalog, collect data from library acceptances, brief shortlists, placements, and statements, then look for patterns in the tracks that perform: their moods, tempos, genres, versions, and uses. Use those patterns to decide what to write more of, which tracks to improve, and where to place them. Review over months, not weeks, because sync results arrive slowly.

Where the data comes from

SourceWhat it tells you
Library acceptances and rejectionsWhich tracks meet each library's standards and needs
Brief shortlistsWhich tracks fit real buyer requests
PlacementsWhich tracks buyers actually chose
Library statementsWhich tracks earn license income, and from what uses
Performance royalty statementsWhich placements were broadcast
Library dashboardsPlays, downloads, or searches, where available

Library analytics and discovery patterns explains what library data can show.

Set up a simple tracker

Record each track with its key attributes and results:

  • Title and versions available
  • Genre, mood, tempo, and energy
  • Vocal or instrumental
  • Libraries holding it
  • Acceptances, shortlists, and placements
  • Income by period

Tracking placements and pitches and tracking income over time suggest layouts.

How to review your catalog

  1. Wait for enough data. Give tracks several months in libraries before judging them.
  2. Sort by results. Which tracks have been shortlisted, placed, or earned?
  3. Compare attributes. What do the strongest tracks have in common?
  4. Look at uses. Are placements in ads, TV, online video, or something else?
  5. Compare libraries. Do some libraries place your music more than others?
  6. Note gaps. Which moods or uses have you not covered?

Patterns to look for

  • Moods. Certain feelings, such as uplifting or tense, may perform better for you.
  • Tempo and energy. Mid tempo tracks may be more versatile than extremes, or the reverse.
  • Vocal vs instrumental. One may clearly outperform the other.
  • Versions. Tracks with instrumentals and edits may be placed more.
  • Structure. Tracks with clear builds and endings may suit editors better.
  • Libraries. Some catalogs may fit your style better.

Acting on what you find

FindingAction
A style keeps getting placedWrite more tracks in that style
A strong track lacks versionsAdd instrumentals, edits, stems
A track is never foundImprove its metadata and description
A library rarely places your musicFocus new tracks on libraries that do
A style is always rejectedImprove it or stop submitting it
A track is datedRefresh it or replace it

Removing or replacing underperforming tracks covers when to retire tracks.

Don't overreact to small numbers

One placement does not prove a trend, and a few months without placements does not mean a track has failed. Look for patterns across several tracks and longer periods. Sync results are irregular, so be patient before drawing conclusions.

Comparing libraries

Use the same data to compare libraries: acceptance rates, placements, statement clarity, and responsiveness. A library that rarely places your music may still suit other styles, so check fit before deciding. Evaluating library performance explains how.

A review routine

  • [ ] Update your tracker when statements arrive
  • [ ] Review the whole catalog every quarter
  • [ ] Note the top tracks and their common traits
  • [ ] Choose one or two changes to make
  • [ ] Check the results at the next review

Common mistakes

  • Judging tracks too early
  • Relying on gut feeling instead of records
  • Writing only what you enjoy without checking what buyers choose
  • Ignoring metadata as a reason for poor results
  • Changing everything at once, so you cannot tell what helped

A hypothetical example

This example is made up. A producer reviews a year of statements and notices that most of his placements are calm, mid tempo instrumentals used in lifestyle and documentary shows, while his high energy tracks rarely place. He adds instrumentals and edits to his calm tracks, updates their metadata with more specific uses, and focuses his next batch of new music on that style.

A sample tracker layout

ColumnExample entry
TrackTitle and code
StyleGenre, mood, tempo
VersionsFull, instrumental, 30 second edit
LibrariesWhich libraries hold it
ShortlistsNumber of brief shortlists
PlacementsNumber and types of use
IncomeTotals by period
NotesAnything learned, such as feedback

Keep it simple enough that you will actually update it.

Reading library feedback

When a library or brief gives feedback, record it next to the track. Comments like "too busy for underscore" or "needs a clearer ending" often apply to more than one track. Over time, repeated feedback is one of the clearest signals of what to change in your writing or production.

Separating track problems from discovery problems

A track that never earns may have a quality or fit problem, or it may simply never be found. Signs of a discovery problem include accurate quality but vague tags, no description, or placement in libraries that do not serve its style. Signs of a track problem include repeated rejections or shortlists that never convert. Fix discovery problems with metadata and placement; fix track problems with production or by writing something new.

Using what works to plan new music

Turn your findings into a short brief for yourself. For example: "More calm, mid tempo acoustic instrumentals with clear endings, plus instrumentals and 30 second edits." Writing to your own brief keeps new work aligned with what buyers choose, while still leaving room for experiments.

Leaving room for experiments

Patterns describe the past. Set aside a small share of your output for new styles, so you can discover what else might work. Track those experiments the same way, and expand them only if results justify it.

Turning findings into a plan

After each review, write down three actions: one type of track to make more of, one group of existing tracks to improve, and one thing to stop doing. Keep the list short so you actually follow it. At the next review, check whether the actions made a difference before deciding what to change next.

Review dates worth keeping

Set review dates and keep them: a quick look each month at new statements, and a fuller review every quarter or half year. Regular reviews make patterns visible sooner, so you can adjust your writing and versions while the information is still fresh. Write the dates in your calendar so they actually happen.

Where That Pitch fits

That Pitch places your music in 100+ non-exclusive sync libraries from one upload, so your tracks can be found by the productions those libraries serve. Your tracks are matched to library briefs automatically, and you keep 100% of your sync placement earnings. Get started free on Lite with unlimited uploads into 1 library per track, sync briefs included, and upgrade to 100+ anytime.

Join That Pitch free

FAQ

How do I know which tracks work for sync?

Track acceptances, shortlists, placements, and statements, then compare the tracks that perform.

How long should I wait before judging a track?

Several months at least, because sync results arrive slowly.

What patterns should I look for?

Moods, tempos, vocal or instrumental, versions, structure, and which libraries place your music.

What should I do with a track that is never found?

Improve its metadata and description, and add versions.

Should I stop writing styles that do not place?

Improve them first, but focus new work on styles with better results.

How often should I review my catalog?

About once a quarter, updating your tracker as statements arrive.

How can I tell if a track has a discovery problem?

Good quality but vague tags, no description, or placement in libraries that do not serve its style.

Last updated

Related reading